Skip to content
NASHSOFTWARE SERVICES
Writing

Published Engineering

Code Audit vs Penetration Test: Which Do You Need?

A code audit reads your software from the inside. A penetration test attacks it from the outside. What each tells you, and which to buy first.

Mike Nash · Fractional CTO and independent code reviewer

People use "code audit", "code review", "penetration test" and "security audit" as if they were the same thing. They aren't, and buying the wrong one can leave you with a tidy report that doesn't answer your question.

Here is what each one is, in plain terms.

A code audit

A code audit, or code and architecture review, reads the source code, the configuration and the running application from the inside. The question it answers is whether the software is sound and ready to rely on. It covers how it's built, how it's released, how it handles data and what breaks first as you grow. The output is a written call and a list of what to fix.

A penetration test

A penetration test attacks a live system from the outside, the way an attacker would. The question it answers is what someone could actually get into today. The output is a list of the weaknesses the tester managed to exploit.

An automated scan

An automated scan runs a tool over the code or the live site and flags patterns it recognises. It's quick and cheap and good at known, mechanical problems. It can't tell you whether the design makes sense or whether a feature does what it claims.

A compliance certificate

A compliance certificate, such as SOC 2 or ISO 27001, judges how a company runs: its policies, access controls and processes. It doesn't tell you whether the software itself is any good.

When to buy each

  • Code audit: before launch, before a deal, or when you take over software and need to know what you have.
  • Penetration test: when you need evidence of how the live system stands up to an attack.
  • Automated scan: as a routine check alongside the rest, not instead of it.
  • Compliance certificate: when a customer, insurer or regulator asks for it.

Which one first?

If you don't yet know whether the software is sound, start with the code audit. It tells you what state things are in, and it will say if you also need one of the others. There's no point paying to attack a system whose basics aren't in place.

If a customer or insurer has asked for a penetration test by name, buy that, and have the audit alongside it, because the two find different things.

Where my review fits

The Confidence Review is a code audit. It isn't a penetration test and it isn't a certificate, and the report says so if you need either. If you aren't sure which you need, get in touch and I'll tell you.

Share